Teensicle appeared in the episode "Boy Bands Will Be Boy Bands". They were a platinum selling band that Clover, Alex, and Sam were sent to investigate when several band members began to mysteriously disappear. Samantha and Clover said that they were Teensicle's biggest fans, and that they were their favorite band "this week" while Alexandra said that she preferred old-school bands from last year when being a boy band actually meant something.

The members of Teensicle were Mikey, T.J., and O-Dog. Both Sam and Clover had mild crushes on all the members of the band. Clover expressed disappointment when she was unable to figure out a way to make any of the band mates her boyfriend and continued to address all 3 as one of her possible "future boyfriends" throughout the episode.